Are Gutter Guards Worth It? Evaluating Their Benefits and Drawbacks

Are you sick of having to climb up and down steps to clean your gutters? You might find the answer you’re looking for in gutter guards. But it’s important to think about the pros and cons before making a choice. Here’s a detailed look at whether gutter guards are a good idea for your home.

mesh gutter guard

What Are Gutter Guards and How Do They Work?

Protective covers called gutter guards are meant to keep things like leaves, twigs, and dirt out of your gutters. The way they work is by making a wall that lets water flow into the drain but keeps bigger things out. There are different types of gutter guards, such as:

  • Mesh Gutter Guards: These have small holes that let water through but catch debris.
  • Screen Gutter Guards: Made from perforated metal or plastic, they require more frequent cleaning.

Each variety has its own style of working, customized to environmental conditions and maintenance requirements.

Benefits of Gutter Guards

A Reddit user recently asked:

Gutter guards? Good or bad?


“In my line of work I’m trying to figure out why someone’s basement is flooding. 90% of the time it has something to do with the downspouts not being extended or the gutters not holding the water. And in most of the cases, the customer has gutter guards.

By their own very nature, gutter guards are going to keep some water out, as well as the leaves they are keeping out. So during even just a medium heavy rainstorm, the water that would have gone into the gutter, and then down the downspout ends up going over the gutter, because 50% of the gutter is covered by something.”

Installing gutter guards can offer several advantages:

  • Reduced Maintenance: One of the biggest benefits is that you don’t have to clean your gutters as often, which saves you time and lowers the risk of falling off a ladder.
  • Prevent Water Damage: By making sure your gutters work properly, gutter guards help stop water from overflowing and damaging your home’s siding, foundation, or landscaping.
  • Control Pests: Mosquitoes, spiders, and other bugs love to live in clogged gutters, so gutter guards can make your home safer in the winter by keeping your gutters clear. For example, ice dams can do a lot of damage to your roof in colder climates.

How Do I Know Which Type of Gutter Guards My Home Needs?

Choosing the right gutter guard depends on various factors:

  • Local Debris: If you have a lot of pine trees around, micro-mesh might be better than screens, which could clog with pine needles.
  • Rainfall: Areas with heavy rain might require guards that can handle high water flow rates.
  • Budget: Metal guards tend to be pricier but more durable, while plastic options are cost-effective but might need more frequent replacement.

Gutter Guard Drawbacks and Limitations

Despite their benefits, gutter guards have some downsides:

  • Small Debris Can Still Enter: Guards won’t stop everything. Tiny particles like pine needles can still slip through certain designs
  • May Affect Aesthetics: Some guards can be visible from the ground and may not blend well with certain home designs.
  • Potential Roof Strain: In heavy snowfall areas, gutter guards may contribute to ice buildup, leading to added weight on the roof.

Choosing the Right Gutter Guard for Your Home

To select the best gutter guard:

  • Assess Needs: Understand your local climate, the type of debris you deal with, and your maintenance willingness.
  • Gutter Compatibility: Ensure the guard matches your existing gutter system.
  • Professional Advice: Consulting with a contractor can help tailor the choice to your specific needs.

Installation and Maintenance Considerations

Even with gutter guards, occasional maintenance is necessary to ensure they function correctly.

  • Installation: Choose a professional gutter installation company for complex systems. Remember, incorrect installation can lead to poor performance.
  • Maintenance: Although less frequent, maintenance is still necessary. Check after storms for debris or damage, and ensure the flow of water isn’t obstructed. Perform regular gutter cleaning for maximium perfomance.

Final Thoughts

Gutter guards can indeed be a valuable investment, significantly reducing the hassle of gutter maintenance and protecting your home from water damage. However, they’re not a magic bullet; they require selection with care, proper installation, and ongoing maintenance.

By understanding both their benefits and limitations, you can make an informed decision that might just keep your home safe and sound for years to come.